More CMBS borrowers pay off balloon mortgage payments on time.
Increasing liquidity and low interest rates are enabling more borrowers with securitized debt to replace their loans at maturity, experts say.
Some 49.9% of the securitized loans that matured in July successfully met their balloon payments, according to New York-based Trepp LLC, which closely tracks the commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) market. That's up more than 11 percentage points from 38.7% the previous month and is the highest level since the end of 2008.
“This shows there is more money out there than people have thought,” says John B. Levy, principal of real estate investment banking firm John B. Levy & Co. “Institutions, life companies and pension funds have money and they're looking to make transactions.”
Variety of lenders?
Trepp doesn't specify how borrowers are coming up with the capital to pay off their loans, but industry experts speculate that a combination of low borrowing costs and increasing liquidity from a range of sources outside the CMBS market are behind the recent improvement in payoffs. With very little new CMBS originations, it's clear that most payoffs on securitized loans are funded with new whole loans or equity rather than securitized debt.
Borrowers with trophy assets have been able to get new financing from foreign investors, insurers, and even a smattering of CMBS transactions. Private equity investors, too, are ready to help some borrowers put together funds to close out CMBS loans, says Levy.
Low interest rates are enabling borrowers to meet the debt service on large loans. The 10-year Treasury rate, a benchmark for long-term lending, fell to a 17-month low of 2.58% on Aug. 16 before edging up to 2.64% the next day. Fixed-rate commercial real estate loans are available for 5.5% today, compared with about 7% a few months ago, according to Levy.
“We're seeing rates that many of us have just never seen before, and it allows people to make transactions and to carry debt that they never thought they could afford,” says Levy. Deals that don't work at 7% may work at 5.5%, he adds.
Some CMBS loan holders can better meet their loan commitments today than in the depths of the commercial real estate downturn. “My guess is that some of the pressure may have been lifted from other deals that they were in and they can now free up some capital,” says Levy.
Until the fourth quarter of 2008, when financial markets had a meltdown following the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers, the monthly average for the number of on-time, paid balloon payments was more than 70%, according to Trepp.
Since the beginning of 2009, there hasn't been a month when even half of the borrowers with CMBS loans reaching maturity were able to make their balloon payments. The average percentage for the past 12 months has been 32.2%.
Researchers are waiting for more data before calling July's surge in the on-time balloon payments a turnaround or an anomaly. “We'd like to see this number at 50% or 60% for three to four months before we call it a trend,” says Manus Clancy, senior managing director at Trepp.
Decreasing asset values across property types since the market peak in late 2007 have made deleveraging necessary for most owners trying to replace mature CMBS loans. Even for owners with the equity to finance with a smaller loan, however, finding a lender is more challenging today than it was three years ago.
Earlier in this decade, CMBS borrowers could replace one securitized loan with another upon maturity. That funding all but dried up in 2009, a year without a single CMBS transaction, says Clancy.
CMBS lending has made a small comeback this year with deals that include a $716.3 million issue by JP Morgan Chase Commercial Mortgage Securities Corp. and a $788.5 million issue by Goldman Sachs and Citigroup. “In 2010, we could see up to 10 conduit deals,” Clancy says. “That would be great progress.”
The loan-to-value ratios on CMBS deals range between 60% and 75%. The financing terms often prohibit subordinated debt on the asset, such as mezzanine loans. Underwriting is based on current rent and signed leases, as opposed to underwriting practices of 2006 and 2007 that often incorporated future rent increases and leasing projections.
July's spike in balloon payment payoffs reflects a slight easing in the stringent underwriting standards that lenders enacted during the financial crisis, experts say. That brings the market closer to historical leverage ratios and is a far cry from when combined debt on a property could exceed 95% of its value. For 50 years, 75% was the standard, says Levy.
An increasing number of securitized lenders are agreeing to loan-to-values between 70% and 75% today as opposed to 60% a year ago, says Clancy, but he believes today's underwriting is sound. “It's lock-solid stuff, which is what investors are demanding in this environment.”
Haves and have-nots
Unfortunately for most of the $227.3 billion in CMBS loans coming due through 2014, securitized debt lenders are focused on top-quality commercial real estate. Owners of less desirable properties get little help from CMBS as they try to repay loans. “It tends to be trophy properties in premiere metropolitan areas that are managing to refinance,” says Clancy.
Seeing nearly half of maturing conduit loans in July being paid off on time is a positive sign for the CMBS market, says Clancy, but he wants to see a CMBS transaction backed by Class-B and Class-C properties beyond primary markets.
Establishing pricing for a pool of loans off the beaten path would set pricing for similar deals and help to re-establish conduit lending for the broader market. “If somebody could get a deal done like that,” says Clancy, “it would open the floodgates for more and more deals to be done through securitization.”