The bleeding may not have stopped in the retail sector since the first of the year, but on the whole the shopping center REITs are doing just fine, thank you. How do you explain the disparity?
In late June, Wolf Camera announced that it was filing for Chapter 11, citing its acquisition of 450 Fox Photo stores in 1998 as a mistake and vowing a return to profitability.
That same week, Gap Inc. announced that the company plans to reduce its headquarters staff of 10,000 by between 5% and 7%. The Gap also scaled back its planned annual square footage growth for 2002 and 2003 from 15% to 10%. That means the specialty retailer will open 200 less stores next year than originally planned. At the close of trading on June 28, Gap shares registered $29.70, well below their 52-week high of $39.13.
The news coming out of the drugstore sector has been equally gloomy. Late last month, CVS Corp. said its per-share earnings would be as much as 8% lower than forecasts for the second quarter. The company attributed the disappointing results in part to customers cutting back their purchases of non-pharmacy items during a softening economy. At the close of trading June 28, CVS shares were listed at $37.80 on the New York Stock Exchange, dramatically off their 52-week high of $63.75. The conventional wisdom now is that not even the drugstore sector is recession proof.
Is the sky really falling?
But against that retail backdrop of falling corporate earnings, consolidation and a slowdown in new store openings, several shopping center REITs appear to be thriving, including Kimco Realty Corp., The Rouse Co., and CBL & Associates Properties Inc., to name a few. As of June 29, Kimco was trading at a near 52-week high of $46.80.
Similarly, CBL was trading at or near its 52-week high of $31.12. With its acquisition of The Richard E. Jacobs Group's interests in 21 malls and two associated centers earlier this year for $1.3 billion, CBL now ranks as the third-largest mall REIT in the U.S. in terms of the gross leasable space it owns.
“You've had a tech wreck and dividends are in vogue,” said Charlie Willett, vice president of real estate finance for CBL, referring to Wall Street's mood swing and REITs' track record of carrying strong dividend yields. In the current economic climate, where there has been a dramatic downturn in tech stocks, the ability of REITs to deliver a 10% to 15% return to investors looks rather favorable, Willett added.
In CBL's case, the market may also be responding favorably to the company's growth potential in a recessionary environment, said Kelly Sargent, director of investor relations for CBL. The company is committed to a substantial renovation of its newly acquired assets from The Richard E. Jacobs Group to attract new tenants and boost occupancies.
And what about the rash of negative headlines? “Some of the research I've seen is that although retail REITs are affected by bankruptcies and tenant closings, the publicly traded companies have some of the best real estate, and therefore will be less affected by tenant closings,” Willett said.
Time will tell.
|Top Ten||Year-to-Date Return||Bottom Ten||Year-to-Date Return|
|1. Crown America||47.5%||1. Center Trust||-18.1%|
|2. Mills Corp||39.0%||2. Weingarten||-0.3%|
|3. Kramont||38.8%||3. Kimco||0.7%|
|4. JP Realty||35.5%||4. Philips International||1.2%|
|5. Sizeler Property||32.5%||5. Saul Centers||2.4%|
|6. New Plan Excel||28.5%||6. Regency||3.7%|
|7. IRT Property||27.7%||7. General Growth||4.3%|
|8. Glimcher||27.5%||8. Federal Realty||5.6%|
|9. Developers Diversified||26.7%||9. Rouse||6.5%|
|10. Agree Realty||26.1%||10. Pan Pacific||6.6%|
|* As of May 24, 2001|
|Source: FactSet, company reports and UBS Warburg, LLC|
Is there an article that you loved or hated? Want to get something off your chest? Send us a letter or an e-mail. Please include your name, address and daytime phone number. Letters may be edited for clarity and length. All submissions become the property of Intertec Publishing Corp., A Primedia Company. Mail to: National Real Estate Investor, 6151 Powers Ferry Road N.W., Suite 300, Atlanta, GA 30339 Attn: Matt Valley. If you wish, you can fax your letter to 770-618-0348 or e-mail Matt Valley at firstname.lastname@example.org.